View profile

You don't need permission to resist

Artless
This issue is about a fundamental contradiction in expecting oppressive powerful systems to “allow” you freedom. Nobody can allow you freedom because you already have it.

"My religion allows me to be an atheist"
Dear “Hindu Atheist”. Saying “my religion gives me permission to not believe in god” is like saying “my jailer gives me permission to not remain in prison”. Atheism is a resistance, not only against the phenomenon of religion, but also against religious authority.
You are trying to have your cake and eat it too. You are trying to claim to be modern and rational while continuing to hold on to your Hindu privilege. Using the Atheist label to uphold a millennia old system of religious authority is an idea that is completely in sync with all else that the modern savarna does - hijacking the language of resistance to try and use it in the service of oppressive systems.
That’s where “Hinduphobia” came from. That’s where all the wailing about “Hindu khatre mein” came from. These are all instances of reframing the slogans of the oppressed to serve oppressive systems.
As far as Atheism is concerned, nobody needs permission from a religion to be an atheist. Modern Atheism arose as a resistance to religious hegemony and authority. To say it is “allowed” by your religion is to strip it of its essence. That kind of Atheism is just another Hindu privilege.
If you only use the phrase Hindu Atheist to differentiate yourself from contemporary European Atheism (focused on personal gods and exclusivist monotheism), you can always call yourself an Indian Atheist or a plain old rationalist.
Related podcast episode
An audio version of this argument can be found in this week’s episode of my podcast. Listen to it on Spotify here or on YouTube here.
Thanks for reading Artless!
Artless is a newsletter that tries to remind you who you are. If you like it, you can support it with a donation here. I’ll see you in the next one!
Did you enjoy this issue? Yes No
Vimoh
Vimoh @vimoh

A daily newsletter that will equip you with arguments you can use in political conversations online and offline. Think of it as your handbook for dealing with toxic propaganda, lying trolls, and clueless centrists.

In order to unsubscribe, click here.
If you were forwarded this newsletter and you like it, you can subscribe here.
Created with Revue by Twitter.
Odisha, India, Earth