View profile

The meaning of hate

Artless
Today’s issue is about something a romance novelist said on Instagram about how bad Reservations were. When people responded in anger, he said he was getting “hate”. So here goes.

Do savarnas owe reparations?
If you think people leaving angry comments on your casteism online is “hate”, then it’s very clear what the problem here is. You don’t know what “hate” means. It’s a problem that someone who writes about love shouldn’t have.
Hate is treating human beings as less than human for millennia and giving generations nothing but pain and humiliation as a legacy. Hate is hogging most of society’s power and resources by claiming to be meritorious simply because of your caste and religion.
Hate is discriminating against people because of their second name and then saying discrimination doesn’t exist and no reparations are owed to them. Hate is denial of systems like caste while enjoying the benefits of it as you sit on top of the pile of cultural privilege.
These aren’t things that should have to be explained to grown men and women. But in addition to caste, we also have a system of denial and defence set in upper caste homes that takes effect from a young age - complaining against Reservations, making “jokes” about SC-ST folks etc.
It’s a way of infantilising an entire generation, keeping it blind to its privilege, making it think that those who have nothing are stealing from them. These same people will applaud when they see YouTube video speeches called “Does Britain owe reparations?” and they will happily lap up anti-racism talking points coming from (upper-caste) NRI quarters. But when it comes to acknowledging their own privilege and the idea that reparations are owed to those that their ancestors oppressed, they’ll turn clueless.
All this talk of Reservations being bad is just the Liberal version of “Hindu khatre mein”. And it’s not going to end until people in balconies with upside-down newspapers acknowledge what “hate” really means. Perhaps then, they’ll actually become capable of love, in addition to just writing about it.
Thanks for reading Artless!
Artless is a newsletter that seeks to destroy oppressive narratives that help fascism survive so that we may get a centimeter closer to an equal society. If you like it, you can support it with a donation here. I’ll see you in the next issue!
Did you enjoy this issue? Yes No
Vimoh
Vimoh @vimoh

A daily newsletter that will equip you with arguments you can use in political conversations online and offline. Think of it as your handbook for dealing with toxic propaganda, lying trolls, and clueless centrists.

If you don't want these updates anymore, please unsubscribe here.
If you were forwarded this newsletter and you like it, you can subscribe here.
Created with Revue by Twitter.
Odisha, India, Earth